New York City Sunset Cruise vs Dinner Cruise - Full Comparison

New York City Sunset Cruises vs Dinner Cruises - Full Comparison

By:Tyler Ford

Sunset cruises and dinner cruises in New York are among the most popular cruise options for tourists visiting the city, and they are also highly recommended by us. Despite the significant price difference between the two, many travelers find themselves choosing between them.

Today, we want to present a detailed comparison between 2 of the most popular cruises offered by New York Water Taxi and NYC Water Cruises. Both cruises receive high user ratings and are considered among the most frequently booked cruises in New York City.

Which cruises did we review and compare?

The 2 cruises we reviewed are:

Statue of Liberty Sunset Cruise by New York Water Taxi - This sunset cruise has received nearly 2,000 verified reviews on GetYourGuide, with an average rating of 4.6 out of 5. The cruise lasts approximately 1.5 hours and costs around $25 per person.

Gourmet Dinner Cruise with Live Music by NYC Water Cruises - This is a very popular dinner cruise in New York, with around 1,000 reviews on GetYourGuide and an average rating of 4.2 out of 5. It is considered one of the most frequently booked dinner cruises in the city. The cruise lasts about 3 hours and costs around $160 per person.

So what are the main differences between the two? Here is everything you need to know:

At a glance

Two of the most popular sunset and dinner cruises in New York

Key differences in duration, departure point, experience style and overall rating.

Sunset Cruise
Statue of Liberty Sunset Cruise
Dinner Cruise
Gourmet Dinner Cruise with Live Music
Duration 1.5 hours 3 hours
Starting location Pier 16, South Street Seaport Pier 36 NYC
Experience style Sunset sightseeing with music Plated dinner with live music
Food & drinks Available for purchase Dinner included depending on option
Overall rating 4.6 / 5 4.2 / 5
Go to cruise page Go to cruise page
Cruise comparison

Sunset cruise vs dinner cruise in New York City

A side by side look at two of the most popular ways to experience the Statue of Liberty by boat.

New York Water Taxi

Statue of Liberty Sunset Cruise

Duration: 1.5 hours

Relaxed sunset sightseeing cruise with skyline views, music and close up views of the Statue of Liberty.

Duration: 1.5 hours · Downloadable audio guide · Overall rating: 4.6 / 5
Overview

Route: Departs from Pier 16 at South Street Seaport and sails around Lower Manhattan toward the Statue of Liberty during sunset.

Landmarks seen include the Brooklyn Bridge, One World Trade Center, Ellis Island and the Statue of Liberty.

What is included

Included: 1.5 hour sightseeing cruise with music, indoor climate controlled cabins and outdoor decks.

Not included: Food and drinks (available for purchase).

Practical info

Departure point: Circle Line Sightseeing Cruises, Pier 16, South Street Seaport.

Tickets are scanned directly from your smartphone before boarding.

This cruise focuses on atmosphere and views rather than narration, making it a relaxed end of day experience.

Who it is best for

Travelers looking for an affordable sunset cruise with great skyline photos and a laid back vibe.

NYC Water Cruises

Gourmet Dinner Cruise with Live Music

Duration: 3 hours

Evening cruise combining a plated dinner, live music and night views of the Manhattan skyline.

Duration: 3 hours · Live music · Overall rating: 4.2 / 5
Overview

Route: Departs from Pier 36 and sails past Lower Manhattan, the Statue of Liberty and surrounding landmarks during the evening.

What is included

Included: Plated multi course dinner depending on option, live music performances and non alcoholic beverages.

Practical info

Departure point: Pier 36 NYC.

Boarding begins 30 minutes before departure.

This cruise emphasizes dining and entertainment rather than fast paced sightseeing.

Who it is best for

Couples and visitors looking for a more upscale evening experience on the water.